Can A Felony DWI Charge Be Reduced To A Misdemeanor Before Trial In Rochester?

When a Rochester resident is arrested for a felony level drinking and driving offense, the case will be removed from the local court and presented to a grand jury.

At the grand jury, the prosecution will present its evidence and, if the jurors agree the charges are supported, the defendant will be indicted on the felony charges.

Following indictment, the case will then proceed at the county court level.

For the most part, the grand jury conducts its business in secret, and neither the defendant nor his or her lawyer is allowed to monitor what is happening in the grand jury room while the prosecution is presenting its case.

As a result, the defendant in a felony DWI case has no way of knowing if the prosecution is actually presenting sufficient evidence to the grand jury to support the charges.

Fortunately for defendants in this situation, once the defendant is indicted, his or her attorney can request that the court review the grand jury minutes to determine whether legally sufficient evidence was presented to the grand jury to support all of the charges in the indictment.

This may be especially important for felony drinking and driving charges which require the prosecution to establish that the defendant has a least one prior conviction for a misdemeanor or felony alcohol-related driving offense within the past ten years.

The Court of Appeals – New York’s highest court – has ruled that to establish this prior conviction at the grand jury level, simply presenting a certificate of conviction for the prior offense is not sufficient to support the charge.

Instead, the prosecution must present additional connecting evidence establishing that the person listed on the certificate is actually the defendant, not just a person with the same name.

If the judge reviews the grand jury record and finds that the underlying drinking and driving charge was not properly established, the felony charge may be reduced to a misdemeanor.

Felony DWI charges carry very serious consequences. If you need an experienced DWI lawyer, call us at 585-484-7432.

Recent Posts

What Happens During a DWI/DUI Arrest in Monroe County, NY?

Driving under the influence (DUI) or driving while intoxicated (DWI) charges are serious offenses that [...]

The Impact of a DWI/DUI Conviction on Your Driver’s License in Brighton, NY

Driving While Intoxicated (DWI) or Driving Under the Influence (DUI) convictions are serious offenses that [...]

How to Choose the Right DWI/DUI Attorney in Orleans County, NY

In Orleans County, New York, facing charges for Driving While Intoxicated (DWI) or Driving Under [...]

The Role of Ignition Interlock Devices in Fairport, NY DWI/DUI Cases

In the realm of DWI/DUI cases in Fairport, NY, the utilization of Ignition Interlock Devices [...]

The Importance of Hiring a Local Lawyer for Your Genesee County, NY DWI/DUI Case

In the realm of legal matters, particularly when it comes to charges related to driving [...]

Debunking the Myths Around DUI/DWI Traffic Violations in Gates, NY

Driving under the influence (DUI) or driving while intoxicated (DWI) charges are serious offenses that [...]

How Prior DWI/DUI Convictions Affect Subsequent Cases in Clarkson

Driving While Intoxicated (DWI) or Driving Under the Influence (DUI) charges are serious offenses that [...]

Can Out-of-State DWI/DUI Offenses Impact Your Scottsville Driver’s License

Driving while impaired is a serious offense that carries legal implications regardless of where it [...]

Leave a Reply