NY Court Declares House to be Haunted

The home buyer,” to his horror, discovered that the house he had recently contracted to purchase was widely reputed to be possessed by poltergeists, reportedly seen by the seller and members of her family on numerous occasions over the last nine years.”  He promptly sued  the seller and the broker  to rescind the contract of sale and recover his damages. The New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department held that even though New York adheres to the “caveat emptor” (buyer beware) doctrine:

  • the seller can not deny the existence of poltergeists on the premises, so the house was haunted as a matter of law;
  • the equitable remedy of rescission of the contract was available to the buyer who not being a “local”, could not readily learn that the home is haunted or be familiar with local folklore;
  • the seller, having publicized “her close encounters with these spirits which fostered the home’s reputation in the community” through magazine and newspaper articles, had a duty to inform the buyer;
  • haunting is not a condition which can be ascertained by a reasonable inspection of the premises;
  • the seller could not deliver the  home “vacant” as required by the contract; and
  • the real estate broker, as agent for the seller, is under no duty to disclose to a potential buyer the ghostly reputation of the premises.

For further information regarding home buyer’s legal rights, see “Free Legal Resources” at WNY-Lawyers.com.

Recent Posts

What are the Steps to Buying a Home in Rochester?

As a Rochester Real Estate Lawyer, first time home buyers often ask me what the [...]

What is a Rented Property Rider?

I am often asked whether or not real estate investors should use a rented property [...]

Rochester Real Estate Attorney Discusses Closing Costs of a Foreclosed Property

I am often asked as an experienced Rochester Real Estate Attorney, about closing costs for [...]

Rochester Real Estate Lawyer Examines the Common Mistakes Real Estate Investors Make

The most common mistake I see real estate investors making as a Rochester Real Estate [...]

Rochester Real Estate Lawyer Examines The New York Property Condition Disclosure Act

The New York Property Disclosure Act is involved whenever properties of one to four families [...]

Rochester Real Estate Attorney Discusses the Role of a Lawyer in a Land Purchase

Nearly every week, someone asks me as an experienced Rochester Landlord Tenant Attorney, “Well, the [...]

Rochester Real Estate Lawyer Explains Environmental Liability Issues

As an experienced Rochester Real Estate Lawyer, I am often asked about liability matters for [...]

Rochester Real Estate Lawyer Discusses Common Mistakes Clients Make

As a Rochester Real Estate Lawyer, I often get questions about what precautions to take [...]

Leave a Reply