Yes, videotaping a consensual act without a partner’s knowledge violates the New York laws against unlawful surveillance. The New York Appellate Division, Third Department rejected the defendant’scontentions that the New York unlawful surveillance law applies only to “peeping Toms” who hide video cameras in locker rooms, bathrooms, and dressing rooms. The law also applies to surreptitious recordings of personal sexual acts for “salacious and lewd” purposes.
The ruling upheld the conviction of a former Colgate University student, for second-degree unlawful surveillance, a Class E felony, for videotaping two fellow students without their knowledge while they had sex with him. He was also convicted of two counts of second-degree coercion for threatening to post the video of one of the women students on the Internet, identifying her by name, unless she consented to having oral sex on camera.
When formerNY Governor George Pataki signed the New York unlawful surveillance bill into law,he had in mind the unauthorized taping of people willingly engaging in sexual acts as constituting criminal behavior under the amendedNew York Penal Law §250.40. “Women throughout New York State have unknowingly been videotaped while engaging in sexual relations,” Pataki wrote in a message accompanyingthe law. “Several women in this category have attempted to file complaints alleging that their partner made these videotapes without their knowledge or permission and are now even posting the video footage on the Internet. These women were turned away without a remedy.”
The court also upheld the listing of the defendant on the state’s Sex Offender Registry. It is within the discretion of judges to order offenders to be listed on the registry when their “history and character” would indicate the potential for future sex-related offenses.
If you are charged with a sex crime, contact criminal defense attorney Robert FriedmanofFriedman & Ranzenhofer, PCnowat 716.542.5444.
Recent Posts
Is Forcible Touching a NY Sex Crime?
WHAT IS NY PENAL LAW 130.52: THE CRIME OF FORCIBLE TOUCHING? You are guilty of [...]
NY Coach’s Sext Messages to Student Are Admissible Criminal Evidence
The New York Court of Appeals (“NYCOA”) unanimously reinstated two felony charges against a former [...]
The Legal Rights of NY Human Trafficking Victims
Criminal Conviction Vacatur Law Expanded New York became the first state in 2010 to enact [...]
Crimes Against a Child
If you are charged with committing crimes against a child, the penalties can be quite [...]
Damage Done: Charges A Hurdle Even When Dismissed
A Troy, NY teenager who headed off to his freshman year at Rochester State College [...]
Penalties For Predatory Sexual Assault Against A Child (NY PL 130.96) In Rochester
Predatory Sexual Assault Against A Child (NY PL 130.96) is one of the most serious [...]
Penalties For Sexually Motivated Felony (NY PL 130.91) In Rochester
When a person is convicted of a crime that has been designated a Sexually Motivated [...]
Penalties For Sexual Abuse In The First Degree (NY PL 130.65) In Rochester
As a D felony, a conviction for Sexual Abuse in the First Degree (NY PL [...]