Landlord Has No Duty To Mitigate

The tenant vacated his apartment before the lease expired and stopped paying rent. The landlord unsuccessfully tried re-renting the apartment and decided to sell the unit, keeping it vacant to make it more marketable. The landlord later sued the tenant for the unpaid rent for the entire lease term.
Landlords no longer have a duty to re-rent residential properties if the tenant breaks the lease, ruled the New York Appellate Division, Second Department. In Rios v Carrillo the court extended to residential tenancies a prior decision by the New York Court of Appeals, holding that commercial landlords did not have to mitigate damages — unless the lease stated otherwise. When a commercial tenant defaulted, the landlord had no duty to try to re-let the property, but could sue the defaulting tenant for the total rents due under the lease term.
ADVICE TO TENANTS: If you plan to vacate your apartment before the end of the lease term, you should attempt to find subtenants or ask your landlord to help you find a new tenant. Landlords of buildings with four or more units can not unreasonably withhold their consent to subletting or assignment of the lease.
ADVICE TO LANDLORDS: It’s still advisable to include a provision in residential and commercial leases that the landlord has no duty to mitigate and a defaulting tenant will be held liable for the rent for the entire term of the lease. Even though landlords do not have an obligation to mitigate, they should still attempt to re-rent the apartment because most judgments against tenants for unpaid rent are uncollectible.
Other states, such as Connecticut and New Jersey impose a duty to mitigate on residential landlords.

Recent Posts

Condo Association Can’t Limit Weight of Emotional Support Animal

In Players Place II Condominium Association, Inc. v. K.P, the New Jersey Supreme Court on [...]

Landlord Sexual Harassment of Section 8 Tenants

The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Office of Inspector General (OIG) conducts [...]

NY Landlord Attorneys Pay $650k for Frivolous Lawsuits

New York Attorney General Letitia James  secured more than $650,000 from debt collection law firm, [...]

NY Source of Income Antidiscrimination Law Ruled to be Unconstitutional

In People vs. Commons West, LLC, the Cortland County New York Supreme Court ruled the [...]

New York Landlord 2024 Legal Compliance Update

Feb 6, 2024 – Landlords and property managers will learn how to comply with federal, state [...]

9 Common Mistakes to Avoid With Emotional Support Animals

Attorney Robert Friedman contributed a fantastic article to RENT Magazine to help landlords avoid legal [...]

NY Landlords and Sellers Must Disclose Flood Risks

Due to unprecedented rainfall and disastrous flooding, New York laws require that sellers of residential [...]

Landlord Can Reject ESA if Other Tenants Are Allergic

Karen Cohen has a medically documented severe allergy to pet dander that causes nasal congestion, [...]

Leave a Reply